That happens to me a lot, too. If I'm too tied up with my own writing, I can't turn it off, and I end up not finishing a book, and I hate that.
I've been on a reading binge the last few days (due to getting some books I'd been wanting to read for a while), and this last one the inner editor pops out once in a while. It's Stephen King's Under the Dome, and while I love his writing, this one could have been edited a tiny bit better. He has characters with similar names, which throws me off my pace until I remember who's who, and often uses the same word more than once in a paragraph -- like the word "clean", for example.
But I'll get over it.
Of course, while I was reading 11-22-63, there was no inner editor at all. I mean at all. Totally hooked me from page one. I think it's probably the best he's ever written, and I don't say that lightly.
The same with Changes, the latest Harry Dresden book. Butcher has his glitches, but that man can tell a story. I hope his next installment doesn't take forever, because I can't wait to see where the plot goes next.