Oh boy. Do I feel like a Fiverr book design veteran!
I think I've ordered covers from five ... or is it six? artists now. Actually I'm still waiting for one last cover to be delivered.
I asked, when I considered it affordable, for the editable PSD file. Because of this, I feel like I "learned" something from each cover I ordered, even if I ended up not using it.
I provide my own photos for the covers. I know my way around Photoshop, but don't feel confident in my designing skills. But, I'm starting to re-think that. Some of these people are so bad, that my own designs are better! That's saying something!
My results:
The first two artists I hired were mixed.
The first was BAD. COMIC SANS MS on the title! NO NO NO! Horrible! But I actually did find their composition-as simple as it was-to be interesting.
The second cover was "okay." It didn't knock my socks off but it was acceptable. I even used it for a little while on my book.
The third and forth artists were both FANTASTIC. I would wholeheartedly recommend them.
In fact I'll link to them:
https://www.fiverr.com/alerrandre and
https://www.fiverr.com/zebastiann I was very happy with what they produced.
I will mention that with all of these artists, following instructions is not always a strong suit. You may have to remind them to get something correct (like the size of the book cover).
Now I'm on the last stretch with two final artists.
I just got a cover from the first of the final two. It was laughably bad. No, I should correct that-I'm sure if I had no Photoshop skills at all, I'd probably be grateful that someone did anything. But all I can say is I can do much better myself, and I don't have the greatest design skills. This person's sense of color was off (hint: If you don't understand color, just keep it simple! Don't try to use color combinations anyway! Holy cow!). The font choice was eh. And what they did with the pictures I sent-oy vey!
Oh well, I thanked them, but won't be giving them a review.
This time around, if I don't get something that knocks my socks off, I'm going with my own design. (Which is not that super great, but I got some ideas from all the other designers I hired!)
I'm waiting for one last designer to come through. It was someone that was recommended here on this thread. I'm pretty sure I'll like what they do, but just in case I won't mention their name.
My conclusion from my fiverr experience is, quality is VERY mixed. Some of these people have no business calling themselves designers. But then again, they are being paid a pittance, so I'm not complaining too loudly. You get what you pay for.
With the prices on Fiverr, the best thing you can do is get some recommendations (like from here) or budget in several tries with several artists to finally find one that you like. Assume that at least 50% of what you get will be rubbish and laugh it off.
And a final thing: I send a tip to the designers who do nice work. They get paid so little, and the tip brings their fee up to something a little less grievous.
