Kindle Forum banner

Honored and validated...

2367 Views 15 Replies 11 Participants Last post by  AmsterdamAssassin
Reprobate - A Katla Novel was reviewed by Hannah Thompson, on her blog 'Blind Spot'.

Hannah's blog is about blindness and its representation. It asks how the blind and the partially blind relate to the sighted and the partially sighted. It mostly focuses on representations of blindness from the nineteenth century to the present day, in English and French culture and society. It also maps the place of a partially-blind academic in a resolutely sighted world.

Hannah Thompson is a senior lecturer in French at Royal Holloway's School of Modern Languages, Literatures and Cultures - her next book Taboo: Corporeal Secrets in Nineteenth-Century France will be published by Legenda in June 2013. Follow her on Twitter @BlindSpotHannah.

Hannah has been blogging since February 2012, but her blog is already listed in the Top 100 Special Education Resources on the Web and listed in the Top 10 UK Disability Blogs.

Hannah's review of Reprobate is reproduced below:
Blindness in Fiction 4: Reprobate: A Katla Novel

It is notoriously difficult for non-blind writers to depict blind characters in fiction. Although anyone can close their eyes and imagine blindness for a few minutes, living in a world where sight has lost its meaning is incredibly hard to imagine. For this reason, blind characters in fiction are relatively rare. Where they do exist, they are either secondary and therefore always described from someone else's point of view (as in Adrian Mole) or evil and not described sympathetically at all (as in Ratburger). Like Star Gazing which I blogged about last April, Reprobate is a novel of shared viewpoints, in which a blind character, Bram, plays a crucial role.

When the reader first encounters Bram, it is easy to mistakenly think that he is nothing but a fascinating plot device. We initially encounter him just after assassin Katla has finished a job. When he interrupts her as she is cleaning up the crime scene, her first instinct is to kill him, as she normally would an 'additional' who might later be able to place her at the scene. But when Katla realises Bram is blind she decides to spare him. Her reasoning is that he poses no threat to her because he will never be able to make a positive identification of her.

Katla, like most sighted people, imagines at first that a world without sight is a world of darkness and confusion. But Bram is not the kind of passive, low-functioning blind person who is frequently found in fictional representations. Unlike the blind man in Amelie, for example, he is always well aware of his environment. He picks up clues from the sounds, smells and atmospheric conditions he senses and is never described as having a lesser experience of life because of his blindness. This is wonderfully demonstrated in the scenes, such as the episode in the diner at the beginning of the 'Luncheonette' chapter, which are told through his perspective. In these scenes, the author focuses only on what Bram can hear, touch and sense. But the reader nonetheless gains a complete understanding of the scene. In fact until you look closely at the language of the scene, you probably won't even notice the absence of visual clues. Bram's presence in the novel, and the part he takes in its narration, brilliantly shows that sight is not essential to a full and happy existence. Bram is clever, funny, sexy and sporty. In fact very soon the story becomes so gripping that the fact of his blindness would easily be forgotten if it weren't for the detail with which the narrator describes the practicalities of his life.

If you want to know what it is like to be a blind person living in a sighted world, then you should read this book, especially if you enjoy complex and multi-layered thrillers with unexpected twists and a truly triumphant ending.
Reprobate has been favourably reviewed before, on Amazon and several websites/blogs, but never by a blind reviewer and critic of media representations of blind characters in fiction, so I'm grateful to Hannah for taking the time to read Reprobate and write such a thoughtful review.

Please visit her blog, if you are interested in blindness and its representations.
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
That's an awsome review.
That is indeed a great validation of your writing.  Well done you & congratulations!  :)
Fantastic. That means you nailed your characters!
Now all I need is an assassin to validate Katla's viewpoint chapters...  ;D
Wow, that's really the best compliment you could get for that character!
How marvelous for you! Congratulations. I checked my job history list and found that I have never been an assassin. I was SO READY to do that review for you. Disappointing.

Wonderful review. I've seen discussions of the lack of realistic blind characters in fiction, so getting a thumbs up from someone who's blind really counts. I have a WIP with a main character who was blinded as an adult. It's a subject I wouldn't normally tackle because I hate doing research and knowing that I'm still likely to come off as a complete outsider. But being married for 30 years to someone who was blind is a pretty good education.
Catana said:
But being married for 30 years to someone who was blind is a pretty good education.
I'll say! Six months drove me batshit. But, yes, it was educational.
Janet Michelson said:
I checked my job history list and found that I have never been an assassin.
It might not be too late for a career change... But if you want to review Reprobate, you're welcome. Check my blog for details.
I'll put it on the top of my reading list. My editing jobs are lining up steadily, leaving few opportunities to do recreational reading, but Hannah's review has piqued my interest. 
Wow, great review!
Congratulations, :).
What a wonderful review. Congrats.
Janet Michelson said:
I'll put it on the top of my reading list. My editing jobs are lining up steadily, leaving few opportunities to do recreational reading, but Hannah's review has piqued my interest.
I sent you a review copy, Janet. Love to hear your opinion.

Incredibly, I tweeted about being 40K into book three, Rogue, and Hannah tweeted right back that she can't wait. She read Peccadillo as well and will post a review about it, and she'd love to be a beta-reader for Rogue! I have a roster of beta readers who are all specialists in fields like forensics, pathology, law enforcement, medical professions, editing, crime, drug addiction, etcetera, but Hannah will be my first blind beta-reader. Like I'm still waiting for an assassin to offer beta-reading... :D

Although Hannah said I've been doing fine so far without a blind beta-reader, it always helps to keep an extra eye on the blind guy... ;D

I also posted Hannah's review on my FB page, and it has been shared, with a visible uptake in sales. Now with the thriller promo of tomorrow, things are looking up. I'd love to get out of the 1 book per day and into 1 book per hour... ;)
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.